Medical Negligence Can Lead to Death for Organ Transplant Recipients

When considering the life-saving potential of organ donations, it is essential for individuals to approach the process with caution and an informed mindset. While organ transplantation has revolutionized medical treatment, cases of medical malpractice surrounding organ donations underscore the importance of vigilance and thorough evaluation. By understanding the potential risks and taking necessary precautions, individuals can make informed decisions to ensure their safety and well-being throughout the transplantation journey.

In an article published by ProPublica, one man’s journey for a healthy heart ends in tragedy. Bob Naedele, a former police detective, received a heart transplant after spending years on the waiting list. Initially, his recovery seemed to be going well, but he later developed a fever and tremors, which led to his return to the hospital. After several weeks, doctors at Yale New Haven Hospital discovered that the heart he received was infected with a parasite that causes Chagas disease.

Despite expert recommendations to screen donors born in countries where the parasite is endemic, the U.S. does not require at-risk organ donors to be tested for Chagas. Some transplant networks in the U.S. screen for the disease, but the New Jersey organ procurement organization responsible for Naedele’s transplant did not. This lack of screening led to Naedele’s untimely death.

The Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network is considering a proposal to require screening of donors born in Mexico or 20 countries in Central and South America, but the proposal has divided transplant professionals. Some argue that screening would be too cumbersome and could delay organs from reaching patients in need, while others believe it is necessary to prevent deaths like Naedele’s.

The high risk of infection from organ transplants

Organ transplantation is a complex medical procedure that saves countless lives each year. However, cases of negligence in the context of organ donations have raised serious concerns and highlighted the need for improved safety protocols and regulations. This negligence can occur at different stages of the transplantation process, from organ procurement to post-transplant care. One significant area of concern, as we have mentioned, is the screening of organ donors for infectious diseases. The risk is not just in getting an organ that is infected; it’s in the potentially limited ability for the body to repair itself later. Organ recipients take anti-rejection medications to ensure that their bodies don’t deem the donated organ itself as a parasite. These medications suppress the immune system. In the event that the organ itself is infected, the recipient’s ability to fight off that infection is compromised – and the ability of doctors to treat the infection may be compromised as well, if the medications can damage the organ.

The failure to screen donors adequately can be attributed to various factors, including the logistical challenges of conducting timely tests and the potential delay in organ transplantation. Organs have limited viability after a donor’s death, making time a critical factor. However, balancing the urgency of transplantation with the need for comprehensive screening is essential to ensure patient safety.

Which infections are most serious for transplant recipients?

Chagas may be rare, but even common infections pose a risk. According to Northwestern Medicine, the most serious risks come from:

• Encephalitis (infection of the brain)
• Meningitis (infection of the brain or spinal cord)
• JC virus (causes progressive multifocal leukoencephalopathy)
• Hepatitis A
• Hepatitis B
• Hepatitis C
• West Nile virus
• Cryptococcal and other fungal infections
• Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (a fatal brain disorder)
• Cytomegalovirus (CMV)
• Herpes
• Epstein-Barr virus (EBV or mononucleosis)
• Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)
• (HTLV) I/II
• Polyomavirus (BKV) (a cold-like virus that stays in your system after childhood)
• Salmonella
• Toxoplasmosis
• Tuberculosis (TB)
• Severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS)
• Syphilis
• Rabies

Negligence in post-op care for organ donation recipients

Acts of medical malpractice can also occur in the post-transplant care of organ recipients. Inadequate monitoring, misdiagnosis, or delayed treatment of complications related to the transplant can lead to serious harm or even death. Proper follow-up care, close monitoring, and prompt intervention are crucial to the long-term success of organ transplantation.

To improve patient safety and prevent medical negligence and malpractice in organ donations, it is crucial to implement robust screening protocols, ensure comprehensive post-transplant care, and foster a culture of accountability and continuous improvement within transplant networks and healthcare institutions. Strict adherence to recommended guidelines, regular audits, and ongoing education and training for healthcare professionals involved in organ transplantation are essential components of a safe and effective transplantation process.

Ultimately, addressing the issue of medical negligence and malpractice in organ donations requires a collaborative effort among healthcare professionals, transplant networks, regulatory bodies, and policymakers. By prioritizing patient safety and implementing stringent protocols, the risks associated with organ transplantation can be minimized, allowing this life-saving procedure to continue benefiting patients in need.

How can a Richmond–based medical malpractice attorney help me?

At Phelan Petty, our dedicated team of Richmond-based medical malpractice attorneys understands the complex and sensitive nature of cases involving organ donations gone wrong. If you or a loved one have experienced complications or adverse outcomes related to medical negligence, our attorneys are here to provide compassionate support and legal guidance.

We will thoroughly investigate your case, gathering evidence, consulting medical experts, and analyzing relevant laws and regulations to build a strong legal strategy. Our attorneys will advocate on your behalf, seeking justice and compensation for the harm caused. We will navigate the intricacies of medical malpractice law, handle negotiations with insurance companies and hospitals, and, if necessary, pursue litigation to ensure your rights are protected. Our priority is to help you hold responsible parties accountable and obtain the compensation you deserve for medical expenses, pain and suffering, and other damages.

By partnering with Phelan Petty, you can rely on our experience, knowledge, and dedication to pursue justice in your case and help you move forward. To schedule a free consultation, call us in Richmond or use our contact page. We proudly serve the people of Richmond and those across Virginia.

Related Content

• Fires Are a Real and Present Danger in the Operating Room
• Multitasking Surgeons Are the Surgery Risk You May Not Expect